Regulatory Compliance

The Prevailing Wage Lives in the Footnotes

The Prevailing Wage Lives in the Footnotes

A subcontractor is carrying two public jobs in Manhattan. One is for a city agency. The other is for a state authority a few blocks away. The estimator builds the second bid off the rate sheet from the first, because it is the same trade, the same local and the same borough.

The steamfitter line looks right. It isn't.

On the City's 2026-27 schedule, a journeyman steamfitter costs $61.80 an hour in wages and $64.89 in benefits. On the State's schedule for New York County, the same steamfitter has cost $71.61 in wages and $56.74 in benefits since October 1. The total package is within about two dollars. The wage is almost ten dollars apart, and overtime, payroll taxes and insurance all ride on the wage.

Nobody gets cited for reading the headline rate. They get cited for the footnote.

Two Schedules Cover the Same Five Boroughs

Both schedules come from the same law. Labor Law Article 8, section 220, requires the prevailing wage on public work. In the five boroughs, two offices publish the rates. The Comptroller of the City of New York issues a schedule for New York City public work. The State Department of Labor issues county schedules for public work let by other public owners.

Which schedule applies follows the contracting entity, not the address. A city agency job and a state authority job across the street can sit on different schedules for the same crew.

The two schedules also run on different clocks. The Comptroller publishes a final schedule around July 1 and posts changes on its website during the year. The State republishes quarterly. The copy in effect now says it was last published November 1, 2026.

The Comptroller is blunt about who carries the risk. Its schedule says an error by the contracting agency in the contract documents "will not preclude a finding against the contractor." Pick the wrong schedule and the contractor owns the violation. The Owner inherits what comes with it: payroll disputes, withheld payments, and a contractor looking for a way to recover the difference.

The Headline Rate Matches. The Package Doesn't.

For many trades the two schedules agree on the number an estimator looks at first. The trouble is everything printed underneath it.

Electricians are the cleanest example. Both schedules show a $64.00 wage. The City lists $70.28 in benefits, then adds a note: the employer owes another 6.2% of taxable gross pay until the worker hits the Social Security maximum. The State lists $74.25, with a note to reduce it by 6.2% once a worker's wages from the same employer reach $184,500. At straight time the two come to the same money. An estimator who copies the City's $70.28 and stops reading is short almost four dollars an hour on every electrician on the job.

Elevator constructors work the same way. Both schedules show $86.43. The City's benefit line is $43.43, with vacation listed separately at 4% to 8% of the base rate depending on years of service. The State lists a single $48.96.

Carpenters run the other direction. Both schedules show $60.05 for building work. The City lists benefits at $50.83. The State lists $42.24, which looks like a bargain until you find $8.39 parked in the wage column, flagged as a benefit that does not take the overtime premium.

Plumbers have identical rates on both schedules, $78.05 in wages and $46.40 in benefits. The difference is when double time starts. On the City schedule, the eight-hour day before double time holds only where the plumbing contract is $1.5 million or less. On the State schedule, the limit is $2 million. On a $1.8 million plumbing package, the eighth hour is double time on a City job and straight time on a State job.

None of this is hidden. All of it is in the footnotes, and footnotes are what get lost when a rate is copied from one spreadsheet to the next.

Move the Split and You Move the Overtime

Three trades show a different kind of gap. The total package is close. The way it is split between wages and benefits is not.

Sheet metal workers are $57.08 in wages and $60.70 in benefits on the City schedule, and $64.82 and $55.52 on the State's. Painters on brush and roller are $45.50 and $45.72 on the City schedule, and $55.76 and $36.72 on the State's. Steamfitters, as above, are almost ten dollars apart in wages.

The totals are within one to three dollars an hour. The wage share is eight to ten dollars apart, and the wage is the part that gets marked up. Premium time is calculated on it. Payroll taxes and workers' compensation are calculated on it. Bona fide benefit contributions generally are not. Two crews with the same package on paper carry a different cost per hour once the job goes to overtime, and every accelerated schedule eventually goes to overtime.

Then there are the steps. The State schedule for New York County shows increases on October 1, November 1, January 1, March 17, April 14 and May 1, and several are marked "to be allocated at a later date." The City schedule carries its own mid-year steps for electricians and elevator constructors. A bid priced on today's rate for a job that runs eighteen months is not priced. It is a guess with a decimal point.

Name the Schedule Before Anyone Bids It

The Owner can't change either schedule. The Owner can decide which one governs, say so, and check that everyone priced it.

Name the issuing office and the schedule edition in the bid documents. "Prevailing wage applies" is not an instruction.

Ask bidders to state which schedule and which publish date their labor is built on. It costs them one line, and it tells the Owner who read the footnotes.

Review certified payroll against that schedule, footnotes included. The 6.2%, the vacation percentage and the overtime trigger are where underpayments hide.

Carry the published steps as escalation, not contingency. They are known increases with dates on them.

On a project labor agreement job, read the PLA too. The Comptroller enforces the agreement's shift, premium and overtime terms on PLA work, so the schedule alone won't tell the whole story.

I built WageHound for this check. It holds both 2026-27 schedules. Give it the rates in a bid and it grades each one against the schedule as a pass, a near miss or a fail. It does not replace reading the schedule. It makes sure someone did. Verify every rate against the official schedule before you bid.

The rate isn't the risk. The footnote is.

Sources: Office of the Comptroller, City of New York, Construction Worker Prevailing Wage Schedule, effective July 1, 2026 through June 30, 2027 (published July 1, 2026); New York State Department of Labor, Prevailing Wage Rates for July 1, 2026 through June 30, 2027, New York County general construction (last published Nov. 1, 2026).